3D scanning
Ambito disciplinare
-
Scene acquisition with multiple 2D and 3D optical sensors: A PSO-based visibility optimization
Sensors Switzerland, 20(6)
Geometric modeling and processing
Abstract
Designing an acquisition system for 2D or 3D information, based on the integration of data provided by different sensors is a task that requires a labor-intensive initial design phase. Indeed, the definition of the architecture of such acquisition systems needs to start from the identification of the position and orientation of the sensors observing the scene. Their placement is carefully studied to enhance the efficacy of the system. This often coincides with the need to maximize the surfaces observed by the sensors or some other metric. An automatic optimization procedure based on the Particle Swarm Optimization (PSO) algorithm, to seek the most convenient setting of multiple optical sensors observing a 3D scene, is proposed. The procedure has been developed to provide a fast and efficient tool for 2D and 3D data acquisition. Three different objective functions of general validity, to be used in future applications, are proposed and described in the text. Various filters are introduced to reduce computational times of the whole procedure. The method is capable of handling occlusions from undesired obstacle in the scene. Finally, the entire method is discussed with reference to 1) the development of a body scanner for the arm-wrist-hand district and 2) the acquisition of an internal environment as case studies.
Keywords: 3D scanning , Body scanner , Computer graphics , Optical sensors , PSO , Sensor placement , Visibility analysis
-
A practical methodology for computer-aided design of custom 3D printable casts for wrist fractures
Visual Computer, 36(2), pp. 375-390
Geometric modeling and processingMethods for medical applicationsProduct design and engineering
Abstract
In recent years, breakthroughs in the fields of reverse engineering and additive manufacturing techniques have led to the development of innovative solutions for personalized medicine. 3D technologies are quickly becoming a new treatment concept that hinges on the ability to shape patient-specific devices.Among the wide spectrum of medical applications, the orthopaedic sector is experiencing the most benefits. Several studies proposed modelling procedures for patient-specific 3D-printed casts for wrist orthoses, for example. Unfortunately, the proposed approaches are not ready to be used directly in clinical practice since the design of these devices requires significant interaction among medical staff, reverse engineering experts, additive manufacturing specialists and CAD designers. This paper proposes a new practical methodology to produce 3D printable casts for wrist immobilization with the aim of overcoming these drawbacks. In particular, the idea is to realize an exhaustive system that can be used within a paediatric environment. It should provide both a fast and accurate dedicated scanning of the hand-wrist-arm district, along with a series of easy-to-use semi-automatic tools for the modelling of the medical device. The system was designed to be used directly by the clinical staff after a brief training. It was tested on a set of five case studies with the aim of proving its general reliability and identifying possible major flaws. Casts obtained using the proposed system were manufactured using a commercial 3D printer, and the device's compliance with medical requirements was tested. Results showed that the designed casts were correctly generated by the medical staff without the need of involving engineers. Moreover, positive feedback was provided by the users involved in the experiment.
Keywords: CAD , Cast modelling , Orthosis modelling , Personalized medicine , Reverse engineering
-
Autologous ear reconstruction: Towards a semiautomatic cadbased procedure for 3D printable surgical guides
Computer-Aided Design and Applications, 18(2), pp. 357-367
Geometric modeling and processing
Abstract
The autologous ear reconstruction surgery, i.e. the reconstruction of the missing ear anatomy with autologous cartilage tissue in case of partial or complete absence of the auricular region, can be extremely complicated due to the unique shape and size of this anatomical region. Operations of sculpting and carving of the costal cartilage in order to realize the ear reproduction require a high degree of manual expertise and experience from the surgeon. The development of surgical aids that can provide the physician with guidelines during the reconstruction is being studied in the literature. However, state-of-the-art techniques do not represent the optimal solution and only partially help in the reconstruction process. They are based on two-or three-dimensional templates of the target anatomy, providing visual support, yet not helping in the actual reconstruction phase, or, in some cases, by providing active aid but not simplifying the procedure sufficiently. In this context, the option of creating custom cutting guides that could actively assist the surgeon both in the pre-operative planning phase and during the surgery was considered. The proposed approach involves the use of surgical guides adopted for the cutting and reconstruction of the individual anatomical elements involved. Through an iterative process carried out in collaboration with the surgeon the characteristics of the surgical guides have been defined. Subsequently, a method that can be applied systematically to model the cutting guides, ready to be printed with additive production techniques was defined. The procedure was designed with a view to a future semi-automatization of the entire process that could make the physician autonomous in the realization of the patient-specific guides.
Keywords: 3D Ear Templates , Autologous Ear Reconstruction , CAD modelling , Personalized Medicine , Reverse Engineering
-
Photogrammetry and additive manufacturing based methodology for decentralized spare part production in automotive industry
Advances in Intelligent Systems and Computing, 1131 AISC, pp. 796-802
Additive manufacturingGeometric modeling and processingImage Processing & Applications
Abstract
Additive Manufacturing is becoming a suitable production process for many industries: it is based on the idea of adding material layer by layer, in opposite to traditional manufacturing processes. This technology shows advantages as design flexibility, internal logistics minimization and product customization that make it perfect to produce customized parts and all the applications where low production rates occur. The production of spare parts for classic or luxury cars is a field where Additive Manufacturing can be adopted because of low demand and relevant costs to manage stocks keeping several different parts in the after-sales inventory. The photogrammetry technique has been investigated to obtain the 3D model of the component to be replaced and send it to decentralized production centers equipped with 3D printers. This approach can enhance by far the supply chain management for automotive spare parts.
Keywords: Additive Manufacturing , Automotive , Maintenance , Photogrammetry , Supply chain management
-
Knee prostheses reverse engineering: A preliminary investigation
Proceedings of the ASME Design Engineering Technical Conference, 9
Geometric dimensioning, tolerancing and inspectionGeometric modeling and processingMethods for medical applications
Abstract
Total Knee Arthroplasty is one of the most commonly performed orthopedic procedures and it is expected to grow in the next future . In the last past years, computer-assisted procedures represent one of the trends that are transforming the way of practicing medicine. Cornering the Total Knee Arthroplasty, digital models of the joints have been used to carry out simulation of their kinematics and mechanical performance. Whilst for the 3D digital reconstruction of the patient geometry several studies have been conducted, an approximated geometry of the prosthesis has been several times employed, with undeniable consequences on the final results. This paper aims at comparing two non-contact reverse engineering technologies to acquire the shape of femoral components employed for total knee arthroplasty. A high-level device (Konika Minolta Vivid 9i) and a mid-low cost laser (NextEngine) has been compared. For the comparison, a systematic procedure of acquisition and elaboration of the results has been adopted in order to have as unbiased as possible results. The procedure involves the use of the proprietary software of the scanners for the elaboration of the raw data and the meshing procedure has been kept the same for all the models. Since the as-is acquired mesh is of high-resolution, a decimation procedure has been carried out in order to make the 3D models lighter and easier to be handled. Once the decimation procedure has been evaluated comparing the original and the simplified models to one another, the digitalized models have been compared with the measurements taken from a coordinate measuring machines. As a preliminary result, the two lasers seem to be adequate to accomplish the reverse engineering process as required by this application. Of course, the mid-low cost laser would be preferable whether the performance will be confirmed to be (statistically) equal.
-
Retopology and simplification of reality-based models for finite element analysis
Computer-Aided Design and Applications, 17(3), pp. 525-546
Product design and engineering
Abstract
Reality-based 3D techniques and Finite Element Analysis share the way the object under investigation is discretized. Although their purpose, the generation methods and the quality metrics are different, both of them ground on the concept of mesh. Unfortunately, a mesh derived from a reality-based technique are not suitable to be used in a finite element solver directly. This paper aims at comparing different methods to prepare computational mesh of geometries derived from non-contact reality-based technologies. A benchmark test object has been acquired with different devices, a triangulation laser scanner, a multi-stripe triangulation scanner and a digital camera, and post processed in order to fix artifacts. Then, two different decimation approaches have been used: a triangular simplification and retopology. The acquired geometry, before and after the simplifications, has been compared with a CAD model employed as reference: mean and standard deviation between the nominal and the acquired geometries have been tracked. Finally, a tensile test has been simulated making use of a general-purpose finite element analysis software and the results have been compared with the exact solution.
Keywords: Finite element analysis , Laser scanner , Retopology , Reverse engineering , Structure from motion
-
Description of the cad-am process for 3d bone printing: The case study of a femur
Proceedings of the International Conference on Industrial Engineering and Operations Management
Additive manufacturingDesign for sustainabilityGeometric modeling and processingImage Processing & ApplicationsMethods for medical applications
Abstract
The present work shows how 3D models extracted from a computerised tomography (CT) scan can be processed to be 3D printed into 1:1 orthopedic scale models, which find unquestionable utility in pre-operative surgical planning. Relying on the CAT-CAD methodology, which produces a 3D surface called “mesh†from diagnostic images of body parts, the CAD-AM process elaborates a volumetric bone model which a cost-efficient FDM printer can work with. The suitable materials for these applications are PLA polymers, due to their thermo-mechanical properties, affordability and ecological sustainability; these anatomic 3D printed models allows surgeons to accurately see bones injuries and trauma, resulting in a minimisation of risk and a much more flowing doctor-patient communication. Furthermore these 3D printed objects can be manufactured with specific density in order to simulate bone tissues, resulting in a useful tool through which experienced surgeons can pass on their knowledge to medical students at a very reasonable cost, overcoming the glaring limitations of two-dimensional images provided by CT scans. Here represented is a 3D printed 1:1 scale model of a femur donated to the Bone Bank of IOR-Rizzoli Orthopaedic Institute in Bologna.
Keywords: CT scan , FDM printer , Orthopaedic Reproduction Model , PLA polymer
-
Indoor mobile mapping system and crowd simulation to support school reopening because of Covid-19: A case study
International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences - ISPRS Archives, 54(3/W1), pp. 29-36
Abstract
Occupancy analyses represent a crucial topic for building performance. At present, this is even true because of the pandemic emergency due to SARS-CoV-2 and the need to support the functional analysis of building spaces in relation to social distancing rules. Moreover, the need to assess the suitability of spaces in high occupancy buildings as the educational ones, for which occupancy evaluations result pivotal to ensure the safety of the end-users in their daily activities, is a priority. The proposed paper investigates the steps that are needed to secure a safe re-opening of an educational building. A case study has been selected as a test site to analyse the re-opening steps as required by Italian protocols and regulations. This analysis supported the school director of a 2-to-10 year old school and its team in the decision-making process that led to the safe school re-opening. Available plants and elevations of the building were collected and a fast digital survey was carried out using the mobile laser scanner technology (iMMS - Indoor Mobile Mapping System) in order to acquire three-dimensional geometries and digital photographic documentation of the spaces. A crowd simulation software (i.e. Oasys MassMotion) was implemented to analyse end-users flows; the social distance parameter was set in its proximity modelling tools in order to check the compliance of spaces and circulation paths to the social distancing protocols. Contextually to the analysis of users flows, a plan of hourly air changes to maintain a high quality of the environments has been defined.
Keywords: Air quality analysis , Crowd simulation , Indoor mobile mapping system , Occupancy analysis , Proximity modelling , SARS-CoV-2 , School re-opening
-
A low-cost ChArUco-based 3D scanner for cultural heritage
IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering, 949(1)
3D technologies for cultural heritagesGeometric modeling and processing
Abstract
In the region of the cultural patrimony, operators use high-resolution orthophotos of paintings for the restoration, monitoring and electronic recording and exhibition purposes. Unfortunately, artworks that are to be restored and/or shown in digital museums are painted on canvas that are far from perfectly planar. Professional documents surrounding an artwork to be preserved in digital collections or museums can therefore be enhanced with information relating to the paintings' 3D structure. This paper proposes both the design of a portable low-cost device that enables the acquisition of 3D geometry of painting and the procedure for triangulation of 3D data. This process uses a set of fiducial markers to set and continuously control the mutual orientation of the laser source and the camera and works accordingly to the principle of laser-camera triangulation.
Keywords: 3D Laser Scanner , Cultural Heritage , Marker Detection , Pose Estimation , Reverse Engineering
-
Outpatient monitoring of Pectus Excavatum: A Neural Network-based approach
Proceedings of the Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society, EMBS, 2020-July, pp. 5388-5393
Image Processing & ApplicationsMethods for medical applications
Abstract
Pectus Excavatum (PE) is a congenital anomaly of the ribcage, at the level of the sterno-costal plane, which consists of an inward angle of the sternum, in the direction of the spine. PE is the most common of all thoracic malformations, with an incidence of 1 in 300-400 people. To monitor the progress of the pathology, severity indices, or thoracic indices, have been used over the years. Among these indices, recent studies focus on the calculation of optical measures, calculated on the optical scan of the patient's chest, which can be very accurate without exposing the patient to invasive treatments such as CT scans. In this work, data from a sample of PE patients and corresponding doctors' severity assessments have been collected and used to create a decision tool to automatically assign a severity value to the patient. The idea is to provide the physician with an objective and easy to use measuring instrument that can be exploited in an outpatient clinic context. Among several classification tools, a Probabilistic Neural Network was chosen for this task for its simple structure and learning mode.
-
Towards a Non-invasive Pectus Excavatum Severity Assessment Tool Using a Linear Discriminant Analysis on 3D Optical Data
Lecture Notes in Mechanical Engineering, pp. 686-695
Image Processing & ApplicationsMethods for medical applications
Abstract
Pectus Excavatum (PE) is a congenital anomaly of the thoracic cage, at the level of the sternal-costal plane, which consists of an inward angle of the sternum, in the direction of the spine. Its incidence, equal to 1 in 300–400 people, makes it the most frequent among thoracic malformations. For a proper care of patients suffering from PE, it is essential to monitor the progression of the disease and estimate its severity, in order to follow the course of the pathology over time and define the correct treatment. To this end, over the years, severity indexes, or chest indexes, have been introduced. Among them, in recent years, the so-called optical indices, calculated on optical scans of the patient's chest, are gaining ground. In fact, the optical scan is faster to apply and prevents the patient from being exposed to radiation. In this work the peculiar morphological features of PE have been examined by extracting various geometric parameters, in order to develop an outpatient support tool for the evaluation of the severity of the pathology and the monitoring of its progression over time. The extracted values have been compared against a ground truth obtained through five independent surveys collected from paediatric specialists. A Linear Discriminant Analysis was performed to determine the accuracy of the classification using the proposed geometric parameters, obtaining positive results.
Keywords: Clinical support , Depth camera , Pectus Excavatum , Severity index
-
Low Cost Device to Perform 3D Acquisitions Based on ChAruCo Markers
Lecture Notes in Mechanical Engineering, pp. 189-200
3D technologies for cultural heritages
Abstract
In the field of cultural heritage, operators make use of high resolution orthophotos of paintings both for purposes related to restoration and monitoring of art pieces and for realizing online documentations and exhibitions. Unfortunately, artworks to be restored and/or presented in digital museums are painted on canvas which are far to be perfectly planar. Therefore, technical documentation accompanying an artwork to be stored in digital archives or museums can be enriched by information related to the 3D shape of the canvas. In this paper, both the design of a portable low-cost device that allows the acquisition of the 3D geometry of the painting and a procedure to triangulate 3D data are proposed. Such a procedure, working using the principle of laser-camera triangulation, is based on the use of a set of fiducial markers to set and continuously control the reciprocal orientation of the laser source and of the camera.
Keywords: 3D laser scanner , Cultural heritage , Marker detection , Pose estimation , Reverse engineering
-
3d acquisition of the ear anatomy: a low-cost set up suitable for the clinical practice
IFMBE Proceedings, 76, pp. 669-678
Geometric modeling and processingImage Processing & Applications
Abstract
The most common clinical treatment for ear deformities or non-congenital abnormalities is the reconstruction of the missing geometry using autologous costal cartilage. The surgical procedure consists in cutting, sculpting and suturing harvested costal cartilage from the patient to recreate an ear shape which is symmetric to the contralateral ear. During chirurgical operation, surgeons needs an accurate 3D template as reference to reproduce the ear. For this purpose, reverse engineering and additive manufacturing techniques can be employed. Specifically, this works aims to develop a reliable, low-cost and user-friendly system, to acquire the healthy ear geometry in clinical environment avoiding head patient's exposition to radiation (MRI, CT scan). An ideal acquisition setup and device have been selected to achieve accurate results. To this end, a casted model of an ear was created as reference, and the best setup was evaluated by comparing the obtained 3D reconstructions with it. Once the setup has been determined, the anatomies of five volunteers were acquired, to test the methodology on human subjects.
Keywords: 3D model , Ear , Microtia , Photogrammetry , RealSense D415
-
A semi-automatic hybrid approach for defective skulls reconstruction
Computer-Aided Design and Applications, 17(1), pp. 190-204
Geometric modeling and processingMethods for medical applicationsProduct design and engineering
Abstract
In cranioplasty surgery, achieving an effective aesthetic shape restoration of the cranial vault is the most important issue to ensure a proper outcome in terms of social and psychological benefits for the patient. To date, the most advanced approach uses CT/MRI data to reconstruct, in a pre-operative stage, the 3D anatomy of the defective skull in order to design a patient-specific prosthesis. In the last years, several techniques have been proposed to improve the applicability of such approach in the clinical practice, but the analysis of the related literature shows still open issues, due to the wide anatomical variability and complexity of the craniofacial anatomy that needs to be retrieved. With the aim to overcome the State-of-the-Art drawbacks, a new semi-automatic hybrid procedure for repairing unilateral or quasi-unilateral (i.e. a single defect slightly passing the sagittal plane) cranial defects is presented. The novel approach is hybrid because a surface interpolation for filling the hole is used together with a template-based reconstruction guided by the healthy counterpart. The procedure, being landmark-independent and avoiding any patch adaptation, represents a valid alternative for the existing approaches also in terms of user's burden, requiring less time consuming and less cumbersome operations. In addition, a new evaluating technique able to measure the symmetry of the reconstruction as well as the continuity between patch and healthy bone is proposed to test the procedure performance. Several test cases have been then addressed to prove the effectiveness and repeatability of the proposed procedure in reconstructing large-size defects of the skull.
Keywords: CAD , Cranioplasty , Reverse Engineering , Skull Reconstruction
-
Strategies for the design of additively manufactured nanocomposite scaffolds for hard tissue regeneration
Acta IMEKO, 9(4), pp. 53-59
Abstract
Additive manufacturing represents a powerful tool for the direct fabrication of lightweight and porous structures with tuneable properties. In this study, a fused deposition modelling/3D fibre deposition technique was considered for designing 3D nanocomposite scaffolds with specific architectures and tailored biological, mechanical, and mass transport properties. 3D poly(ε-caprolactone) (PCL)/hydroxyapatite (HA) nanocomposite scaffolds were designed for bone tissue engineering. An optimisation design strategy for the additive manufacturing processes based on extrusion/injection methods was at first extended to the development of the PCL/HA scaffolds. Further insight into the effect of the process parameters on the mechanical properties and morphological features of the nanocomposite scaffolds was provided. The nanocomposite structures were analysed at different levels, and the possibility of designing 3D customised scaffolds for mandibular defect regeneration (i.e., symphysis and ramus) was also reported.
Keywords: Additive manufacturing , Design of Experiments , Nanocomposites , Reverse Engineering , Scaffold Design and Analysis
-
Customised multiphasic nucleus/annulus scaffold for intervertebral disc repair/regeneration
Connective Tissue Research, 61(2), pp. 152-162
Additive manufacturingMethods for medical applicationsProduct design and engineering
Abstract
Background: In the case of a degenerated intervertebral disc (IVD), even though spinal fusion has provided good short-term clinical results, an alteration of the spine stability has been demonstrated by long-term studies. In this context, different designs of IVD prostheses have been proposed as alternative to spinal fusion. However, over the past few years, much of the recent research has been devoted to IVD tissue engineering, even if several limitations related to the complex structure of IVD are still presented.Purpose/Aim: Accordingly, the aim of the current paper was to develop a strategy in designing customised multiphasic nucleus/annulus scaffolds for IVD tissue engineering, benefiting from the great potential of reverse engineering, additive manufacturing and gels technology.Materials and Methods: The device consisted of a customised additive-manufactured poly(ε-caprolactone) scaffold with tailored architectural features as annulus and a cell-laden collagen-low molecular weight hyaluronic acid-based material as nucleus with specific rheological and functional properties. To this aim, injectability and viscoelastic properties of the hydrogel were analyzed. Furthermore, a mechanical and biological characterization of cell-laden multiphasic nucleus/annulus scaffold was performed.Results and Conclusions: Analyses on the developed devices demonstrated appropriate viscoelastic and mechanical properties. As evidenced by rheological tests, the hydrogel showed a shear-thinning behaviour, supporting the possibility to inject the material. The mechanical characterization highlighted a compressive modulus which falls in the range of lumbar discs, with the typical initial J-shaped stress–strain curve of natural IVDs. Furthermore, preliminary biological tests showed that human mesenchymal stem cells were viable over the culture period.
Keywords: additive manufacturing , gels , intervertebral disc , Polymers , reverse engineering , tissue engineering
-
Analysis of RGB-D camera technologies for supporting different facial usage scenarios
Multimedia Tools and Applications, 79(39-40), pp. 29375-29398
Image Processing & Applications
Abstract
Recently a wide variety of applications has been developed integrating 3D functionalities. Advantages given by the possibility of relying on depth information allows the developers to design new algorithms and to improve the existing ones. In particular, for what concerns face morphology, 3D has led to the possibility to obtain face depth maps highly close to reality and consequently an improvement of the starting point for further analysis such as Face Detection, Face Authentication, Face Identification and Face Expression Recognition. The development of the aforementioned applications would have been impossible without the progress of sensor technologies for obtaining 3D information. Several solutions have been adopted over time. In this paper, emphasis is put on passive stereoscopy, structured light, time-of-flight (ToF) and active stereoscopy, namely the most used technologies for the cameras design and fulfilment according to the literature. The aim of this article is to investigate facial applications and to examine 3D camera technologies to suggest some guidelines for addressing the correct choice of a 3D sensor according to the application that has to be developed.
Keywords: 3D cameras , 3D face analysis , Sensors , Stereoscopy , Structured light , ToF
-
Automatic calibration of a two-axis rotary table for 3d scanning purposes
Sensors (Switzerland), 20(24), pp. 1-21
Abstract
Rotary tables are often used to speed up the acquisition time during the 3D scanning of complex geometries. In order to avoid manual registration of the point clouds acquired with different orientations, automatic algorithms to compensate the rotation were developed. Alternatively, a proper calibration of the rotary axis with respect to the camera system is needed. Several methods are available in the literature, but they only consider a single-axis calibration. In this paper, a method for the simultaneous calibration of both axes of the table is proposed. A checkerboard is attached to the table, and several images with different poses are acquired. An optimization algorithm is then setup to determine the orientation and the locations of the two axes. A metric to assess the calibration quality was also defined by computing the average mean reprojection error. This metric is used to investigate the optimal number and distribution of the calibration poses, demonstrating that the optimum calibration results are achieved when a wider dispersion of the calibration poses is adopted.
Keywords: 3D scanning , Optical system , Rotary table calibration
-
A method for similarity assessment between death masks and portraits through linear projection: The case of Vincenzo Bellini
Digital Applications in Archaeology and Cultural Heritage, 17
3D technologies for cultural heritagesAdditive manufacturingImage Processing & Applications
Abstract
The aim of this study was to confirm the identities of numerous portraits attributed to the composer Vincenzo Bellini by using 3D-to-2D projection. This study also followed on from earlier research on three death masks of Bellini, the results of which had shown that the wax mask in Catania's Bellini museum best represented Bellini's face compared to the other two. This study used the aforementioned 3D wax death mask obtained through Reverse Engineering as a reference for a morphometric comparison with 14 other portraits. For each portrait, the linear 3D-to-2D transformation M was found which minimized the distance between the 2D landmarks in the picture and the projected landmarks on the 3D mask. This normalized the distances considering the scale of the portrait and the final dissimilarity score with the mask. In particular, the analytical results were able to identify two portraits which particularly resembled the 3D death mask providing future researchers with the chance to carry out historical-artistic evaluations. We were also able to develop a new tool – Image Mark Pro - to easily annotate 2D images by introducing landmark locations. Since it was so reliable for manually annotating landmarks, we decided to make it publicly available for future research.
Keywords: 3D death mask , 3D-2D comparison , Face recognition , Landmarks projection
-
Generative design and topology optimization of disk brake floating carrier
ASME International Mechanical Engineering Congress and Exposition, Proceedings (IMECE), 6
Additive manufacturingDesign methods for mobilityProduct design and engineeringVirtual prototyping and digital twin
Abstract
In the last past years, computer-Aided technologies to improve existing products by widening the design space have been largely investigated. Topology optimization and generative design are two of the most representative technologies of such kind. This paper aims at investigating the use of generative design and topology optimization techniques to improve products whose design has not changed radically over the years. The product under investigation is a disk brake floating caliper that is the most common solution for commercial vehicles. In general, increasing the stiffness of the floating caliper while keeping its weight under control is desirable both from performance and fuel consumption point of view. The solution here proposed aims at exploiting two new ways to approach the engineering design process and evaluate which one is more suitable for problems of this kind. Starting from the original carrier shape, acquired with laser scanning, the two technologies have been applied on the same initial conditions. The initial design space volume corresponds to the acquired shape, the loads and the constraints for the simulation have been drawn reasonably to resemble the actual operating conditions. Keeping the input parameters constants, two different off-The-shelf software packages have been used to perform the computation and with the objective of maximizing the stiffness of the carrier while reducing its mass. The comparison and the improvements on the final designs have been drawn taken as reference to the original caliper..